area.gif (3026 bytes)
shapes.gif (8255 bytes)

Using Angle Measurements and Square Dot Grids

Jay Yohe
Susquehanna Township High School
Grades 11-12 Trigonometry


Prerequisite skills NCTM (PA) Standards Lab Objectives Materials Sample Project Image & Project Objective
Area of Irregular Shapes Procedure Monte Carlo Probability Method Student Project Image & Solutions Grading Rubric Handouts

Prerequisite skills:

Geometry and Algebra
II Knowledge of the “Law of Sines” for computing lengths and area


NCTM (PA) Math Standards:

  • 2.2.11.D -- Describe and explain the amount of error that may exist in a computation using estimates.
  • 2.2.11.E -- Recognize that the degree of precision needed in calculating a number depends on how the results will be used and the instruments used to generate the measure.
  • 2.3.11.B -- Measure and compare angles in degrees and radians.
  • 2.3.11.C -- Demonstrate the ability to produce measures with specified levels of precision.
  • 2.4.11.E -- Demonstrate mathematical solutions to problems (e.g., in the physical sciences).
  • 2.5.11. A -- Select and use appropriate mathematical concepts and techniques from different areas of mathematics and apply them to solving non-routine and multi-step problems.
  • 2.5.11.B -- Use symbols, mathematical terminology, standard notation, mathematical rules, graphing and other types of mathematical representations to communicate observations, predictions, concepts, procedures, generalizations, ideas and results.
  • 2.5.11.C -- Present mathematical procedures and results clearly, systematically, succinctly and correctly.
  • 2.5.11.D -- Conclude a solution process with a summary of results and evaluate the degree to which the results obtained represent an acceptable response to the initial problem and why the reasoning is valid.
  • 2.7.11.B -- Apply probability and statistics to perform an experiment involving a sample and generalize its results to the entire population.
  • 2.9.11.I -- Model situations geometrically to formulate and solve problems.

Lab Objectives:

  • Students will measure angles of triangles with protractors.
  • Students will calculate area of triangles using the “Law of Sines”, “Heron’s Formula”, “Divide and Conquer” and “Pick’s Method”.
  • Students will construct triangles from irregular shapes on Square Dot Paper.
  • Students will use the “Monte Carlo” procedure to predict area via probability.
  • Students will analyze solutions from the different procedures for calculating area to decide the accuracy of their results.

Materials:

  • Handouts (located at the bottom of this lab)
    • Lab Sample Hand-out
    • Student Project problem Hand-out
  • Protractor
  • Graphics Calculators
  • Geometric Sketchpad (to make more irregular shapes)

 


Area of Irregular shapes using Triangles:

Sample and Procedures:
Observe the grid below (each grid square represents 1 square unit):


LabImage1.jpg (19667 bytes)


Project Objective:
Find the area of the irregular portion of the grid (lower left portion) using only triangular portions. Student pairs will compute the area via counting grid points and measuring angles (with a protractor) only. Students will not rely on a ruler to measure sides. Use the following methods to find the area of the figure:

  • Divide and Conquer
  • “Law of Sines”
  • Heron’s Formula
  • Pick’s Method
  • Monte Carlo

Procedure:

Count grid marks to find the area of the rectangle. For this example, the length measures 18 units and the width measures 10 units. The rectangle has an area of 180 square units. This information will be used with the Monte Carlo method.


“Divide and Conquer”:

  1. Break up the figure using the Divide and Conquer Method of approximating square units. In this method, try to break the object up into squares and right triangles. This is the only option that will allow you to use non-triangular objects. Observe one way to break up the irregular shape using “Divide and Conquer”:
  2. LabImage2.jpg (21926 bytes)

  3. Find the areas of each figure you drew and calculate the area of the irregular shape.
  4. Mathform1.jpg (15097 bytes)

  5. Use “Divide and Conquer” again but only break the irregular shape up into right triangles. Observe one possibility (the figure below was reduced to save space):

    LabImage3.jpg (11404 bytes)

    Find the Area of all four Right Triangles:

    Mathform2.jpg (19464 bytes)


“Use “Law of Sines” Area Formula”:

  1. Break the irregular shape up into two triangles only. Make sure you find a pair of triangles so that you can count the unit measure of one side.

    LabImage4.jpg (20812 bytes)

  2. Observe the “Law of Sines” area formula:
    Mathform3.jpg (6996 bytes)
  3. Use your protractor to measure the angles of both triangles.
    LabImage5.jpg (22830 bytes)
  4. Use the “Law of Sines” and/or count obvious units to find the measure of at least two sides of each triangle. Use these results to calculate area:

    Solutions:
    Mathform4.jpg (39307 bytes)

“Heron’s Formula”:
Mathform5.jpg (5062 bytes)

  1. Since you already found two sides for each triangle in the previous exercise, all you need to do first is find the final sides of each triangle using “Law of Sines”.
  2. Solve each triangle using Heron’s Formula and sum the results:
    Mathform6.jpg (58735 bytes)

Pick’s Formula:
Pick’s formula uses boundary and interior points as follows:
Picks.jpg (1855 bytes)
     *b --> number of points on the boundary of the region
     *c --> number of points in the interior of the region
There are 15 points on the boundary and 26 points in the interior.

Solution:
Mathform7.jpg (4212 bytes)


Monte Carlo Area Method:

This is a rather unique method of using Probability to find the area of an object. Suppose the rectangle holding the irregular shape is a dartboard. If darts were randomly thrown at the dartboard, the percentage of darts that hit inside the irregular object compared to the total darts thrown, should approximate the area of the irregular object. This can be accomplished by using the Graphing Calculator’s random number operations.

The grid used in this activity is18 units by 10 units. Therefore, we must consider the coordinates of the dartboard as 18 by 10. Use the calculator to chart 20 dart-tosses and tabulate how many hit within the interior of the irregular shape. You have to decide whether to include the boundary points between the two shapes. Try the experiment using both.

Place the random X values in L1 of your calculator and the random Y values in L2 of your calculator:
MATH – PRB – (5) randInt()
Enter: randInt(0,18,20) --> L1      Note Store Function: “-->” is the STO--> key on your calculator!
Enter: randInt(0,10,20) --> L2

Results:

Make a chart of L1, L2 values (see below) and mark all hits within the interior with a symbol (*).

What percent of the time did the coordinates end up within the interior of the irregular shape?
For the example below, the interior region was hit 4 times out of 20 or 20%.

Now find 20% of the total area of the rectangle:
.20(180)=36 square units

What could improve the accuracy of this method?

Does including the boundary make the answer better or worse?

X Values (L1)

Y Values (L2)

Interior (*)

13 5

 

16 2  
7 1 *
2 3 *
8 6  
18 1  
13 7  
10 0  
12 6  
17 3  
12 0  
15 10  
10 9  
6 2 *
4 7  
11 2  
16 1  
2 8  
8 2 *
8 6

 


TI-83 Calculator Screens
rand1.gif (2416 bytes)

rand2.gif (2367 bytes)

rand3.gif (2012 bytes)




Now use the following image to accomplish the same tasks. Use each area method illustrated in the sample. Show all work and constructions. Students should be given multiple copies of the diagram below:

LabImage6.jpg (25581 bytes)

 


Solution:

LabImage7.jpg (37812 bytes)

 


Rubric:

Points Issued

Criteria

20 points Students accurately used all methods for calculating the area of the irregular shape and showed all work and answers. Students compared results and made statements regarding the accuracy of their answers.
15 points Students used all methods for calculating the area of the irregular shape and showed all work and answers. Students had a minor error in computation on one or two of the methods
10 points Students used all methods for calculating the area of the irregular shape and showed all work and answers. Students had errors in computation on more than two of the methods.
5 points Students did not use all area methods and/or made more than five errors in computation
0 points Virtually no effort was placed on calculating area of the irregular shape using various methods.

 


Handouts:
Sample Image:

Handout1.jpg (19667 bytes)

Handout1.jpg (19667 bytes)

 


Project Handout:

 

Handout2.jpg (24446 bytes)

 


Susquehanna Township School District

Mr. Yohe's Web Pages

© J. Jay Yohe Jr. -- July 2002